Supermodels and the mortgage crisis
March 10th, 2008
As Dan and I have taken to watching the Nightly News, we’ve seen quite a lot lately about the rising rate of foreclosures and the mortgage crisis. Even after such prolonged exposure to the trauma that families are facing, no longer able to afford their homes, I remain hardhearted to any kind of bailout. I believe that the crisis arose from the fact that a large percentage of the people now losing their homes had no business taking out mortgages in the first place. But more on that in a moment.
The other day, I led a discussion with my students about the rhetoric of advertising. We were examining an ad from The Body Shop that had the tagline “There are 3 billion women who don’t look like supermodels and only 8 who do,” accompanied by a photo of a naked, Rubenesque plastic doll with a Barbie head stuck on her, posed seductively on a couch. By a very large majority, my students were repulsed by the image and could not wrap their heads around the message of the ad: that women need to become comfortable with not conforming to supermodel standards. Instead, a significant portion of my female students argued that it’s not that hard to look like a supermodel, and that there are more than 8 women who do, and, essentially, “I’m as hot as a supermodel, so don’t try to tell me I’m not.” There was nothing I could do to get them to even open their minds, let alone change them.
(Read more…)